Check out my guest post over at Roxy's blog where I reviewed the Fragrant Valley Dress, the State Fair Dress (which I keep wanting to call the State FARM Dress), the Vittorio Epaulette Tank, the Followspot Tank (*shudders*), the Magnified Geranium Blouse, and the Skybound Button Up (which I bought!)
Lots of people have commented about the Followspot Tank which is so so pretty and yet looks so so awful on me. The general idea is that I'm pretty brave for posting the picture online (especially on Roxy's blog which has many many more daily readers than I could ever dream of!) I have to be honest: a few years ago, I wouldn't have posted this photo online.
But I'm happy to say that I've reached a point in my life where I'm happy with my body. I run 15-25 miles a week and do yoga. I eat ice cream. I eat lots of ice cream. About six years ago, I was a size 6 on top and 10 on the bottom. I exercised constantly and lived on salads and salmon. Life wasn't particularly fun.
I was also still pear shaped and I've come to accept that I'll always be. No matter how little I eat or how much I exercise, my bottom half is never going to be smaller than a 10 so why freak out about it?
And you know what? This blouse looking so freakish on me (like a funhouse mirror as RedLeslie said and I completely agree!) is just that: the blouse looks freakish on me. It's not a commentary on me or my body. Obviously I have looked nice in clothes before and I will look nice in clothes again, but this particular blouse just didn't work on me. There's no reason for me to be embarassed or upset about that (other than the fact that the blouse is really pretty!)
In my mind, my willingness to post these pictures of me not necessarily looking 100% awesome will help other people learn to love and accept their bodies too. Someone who is a size 0 doesn't look great in everything she tries on so why should us size 8+ girls expect that we should! It's crazy!
On to more reviews (of things that I am pleased to report looked slightly better on me)!
Botany Lesson Tank ($68), size Medium
I actually tried on this top with two separate bottoms to give it the benefit of the doubt. First, I had on the Alena Skirt, which flared out quite a bit (and frankly did my hips no favors). The extra fabric of the skirt was making the bottom of this tank flare out as well so I put pants on to see if that made a difference. It did, but only slightly. This top is a t-shirt which means lightweight t-shirt material. The lack of structure around the bottom of the top makes me look a little bulky. It also seemed a bit on the big side to me - usually a Medium is much more fitted than this on me. It's not really the kind of top that I'd tuck in (because of the pretty pattern on the bottom) so if it doesn't work untucked, it's really not going to work. This and the Followspot Tank are about the same length which is just a bit too long for me. Too bad because I was excited about this tank when I first saw it online. Very pretty but not for me.
Blue Book Blouse ($68), size 12
This blouse came in two color choices - white with a light blue pinstripe and a cornflower blue with a navy pinstripe. Because I am physically incapable of buying blouses in any color besides white, I tried that one on. No 10 available so I grabbed the 12 which fit fine. The blouse itself is pretty sheer and I'd need a white or nude tank to wear underneath, but that's not a huge deal. The ruffles are subtle and the princess seams give the blouse a nice shape. This blouse was a little long for me to imagine wearing untucked (but I rarely untuck blouses anyway), but the length would be perfect to tuck into a skirt or pants for work. Overall, I did think this was a pretty blouse that looked nice on, but since it is a work "staple" I didn't want to buy it before evaluating what I already have. It's on my wish list.Shoofly Trench ($198), size 10
Since there was no Two Paths Trench available to try on, I grabbed the Shoofly Trench for sizing purposes. The 10 fit me perfectly so that's what I ordered in the Two Paths Trench. I liked this trench on, but it seemed a little plain for $200. The belt was also really short (only 2-3 inches excess to buckle). The material is a nice weight and I could see getting away with this well into the New England fall. I'm a total sucker for jackets with a belt or cinched waist because that's the smallest part of me - if it has a belt, I'm probably going to like it so I did really like this. I'd consider it if the Two Paths Trench is a nightmare on, but the details on this are a little boring for my taste.
Blooming Sapphire Wrap Dress ($148), size 8
The largest size my store had was an 8 so I grabbed it since the skirt seemed relatively full. This dress has a lot of interior structure going on to keep the wrap closed - there are buttons and a wrap that tucks through the side and stretches around the back. I wasn't able to get the buttons fastened so I just have the dress tied in these pictures - I definitely would have needed the 10 if I wanted to buy this one. This dress was a little weird for me - the bottom was bulky and then the surplice top was small. That's terribly unusual for me - if anything the bottom is tight and the top is big. The front was also really low cut - I don't know how much difference being able to button the buttons would have made. This dress is very pretty but I wasn't in love.
So I ordered the Drifting By Dress and Two Paths Trench on Friday (and I may or may not have thrown in the Blooming Brushworks Cardigan). See what free shipping does to me? I lose my freakin' mind and start ordering stuff like a crazy person. Ann Taylor, take note!
I have visions of wearing the Drifting by Dress to afternoon tea at my father-in-law's wedding weekend in a few weeks so I'm hoping it works. When my purchases arrive, I'll put up some reviews!
Enjoy your weekend, everyone!
i agree about the mixed patterns. I *think* I like it! lol. To me, it looks like it works, but my brain keeps telling me that's impossible. Oh and thanks for trying on the shoofly trench, I like it, but agree that it's kinda boring compared to the one on its way to you! can't wait to see the drifting by dress!!!
ReplyDeleteFirst of all, you're so awesome! I'm really glad I found your blog or your found mine or whatever.
ReplyDeleteThe mixed patterns look good as a starting point but I think what it needs it for the skirt or top to be a bigger pattern. Does that make sense? I'm no expert on this but I'm thinking that with both being smaller prints it makes it seem too busy. And I think the color scheme of the two patterns should be in the same family. (It is hard to tell but the skirt look black & white? And you have the cardigan matching the top more than the top matching the skirt.) And then possibly have the cardigan be a different pop of color that still compliments the color scheme you are working with. What do you think? When it gets warmer you could replace the cardigan with a light scarf for the pop of color. I guess what I’m saying is right now it looks like the top half matches with the bottom half being different. So what if the main outfit was matching colors with mixed patterns and then contrast cardi. Of course it is highly possible that I have no idea what I’m talking about :D
Oh yay, you bought the items I liked best! I do think it's an important thing to remember-- clothing is meant to fit and flatter you. It seems so basic, but it's so easy to get caught up with the idea that we are meant to fit the clothes!
ReplyDeleteThanks for these reviews, particularly the blouse. I'm chronically in search of pretty white tops since that's what I live in at work.
I think you were right not to wear the paisley skirt with that top. Maybe it's just that the blouse and the skirt are both so pretty that I don't know where to look.
ReplyDeleteI'm built like a stick, no shape, no shoulders. Turns out I have a petite torso with tall-sized arms. My waist is a size bigger than my chest. MANY things look freaky on me. I've yet to find an Anthropologie top I can wear. It is hard not to get frustrated, but I suppose it's like this for all women except a handful of supermodels. We just have to figure out what works on us.
Thanks for the feedback everyone - the issue for me is lack of patterns owned so that makes it hard to mix them doesn't it? Now that I'm aware of the issue, I can start to expand my wardrobe from just the basic stuff that I have in droves! Sometimes I wish I could hire Stacy London or Tim Gunn for one day to just shop with me and put outfits together for me!
ReplyDeleteLeslie - thanks! You're awesome too! It's so nice how all this blogging becomes a little community!
Kathryn - if white shirts are what you're looking for then I'm your gal! I have like 10!
Lady Cardigan - I don't get why woman assume the problem is them when something doesn't fit! No - it just doesn't fit! Go up a size if needed or find something else! Why do we care so much about a number?
Ooh, great reviews Kathleen! Well firstly I have to say that I love your outfit of the day: the mix of patterns is incredible and somehow goes together so well, I think you totally triumphed in your challenge!
ReplyDeleteSecondly, psyched to finally see a photo review of the Shoofly Trench -- I've been so curious about it (though of course less excited about it than the Two Paths). I actually think on you it looks like the fit is pretty spectacular for a trench coat! Also I'm really curious the pinstripe blouse too -- I saw it on the British Anthropologiest, but it's so good to see another review. Hopefully it will make it into my local store soon!
Lastly, your words on body image are so on -- I think it's so easy to forget that clothes are supposed to flatter *you* when you're in a dressing room, your not supposed to conform to the clothes. It's way too easy to feel down about it, but there's no reason too really.
Hi I just stumbled across your blog! I was looking up the shoofly trench because I just bought it (don't worry, no offense taken, I understand your point, but I just LOVE it). The drifting by dress is the most incredible thing I have ever seen. I continue to stare at while I should be studying. Thanks for posting these! When I can't be at Anthro, reading about it is the next best thing.
ReplyDelete